Showing posts with label Multimedia Journalism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Multimedia Journalism. Show all posts

Saturday, July 4, 2009

Unethical Publishing Practices in India

I received a call from Better Photography magazine on Friday July 3, with an urgent requirement of a top-quality image that "defined Goa" and would "make photographers want to come to this coastal tourist state in western India." The image was to go with an article on Goa in the magazine.


After a quick email interaction (reproduced below), I was shocked to learn they wanted the images for free! This coming from India's top magazine dedicated to photography enthusiasts and with ads from the majors like Canon and Nikon. What was even more shocking is the reason for the no fee policy - the magazine I was told, had an estimated readership of 150,000. Hence, I suppose, photographers should feel privileged to have their images published.

I felt the need to post my response to this blog to inform others about this major scam. If sufficient photographers and creative individuals let it be known this is unacceptable business practice, perhaps the scene could be changed.

Here is my response to the email from Better Photography:

Hi Neha,

I am very happy to hear of the readership figures of Better Photography magazine. However I am also disturbed over the policy to use images without any fees.

As a professional working in the field, I believe your 'no fees' policy for photographs solicited from individuals (amateurs and professionals) is a bit skewed. While on the one hand BP informs people on making good images, on the other hand the magazine will not support the livelihood of those working in the same field?

At a cover price of Rs 100 and supported by ads of majors in photography, the publication is purely commercial and not a non-profit. As such, not paying for images and to say that photographers should be happy with 'publicity' in the form of a credit line "given the 150,000 odd readership", is an un-ethical business practice.

If viewership figures is the only criteria then photographers would be better off with images on Flickr where the hits are in the millions and visibility much higher. But of course, for us in the field, it's not just about visibility but also hard cash.

Unfortunately, this practice is being followed by more and more reputed publications - newspapers, magazines and journals, stepping on the already flattened stomachs of photographers and other creative individuals and, in particular, photojournalists.

But as a premier photography publication in India, Better Photography would be expected to do better.

I do hope BP changes its policy to show the way for other publications in India. If not you may just be killing the industry already reeling from editorial cuts in mainstream publications.

In the meanwhile, I must decline having my images published in BP for free.

Sincerely,

Gasper DSouza
gasperdesouza.com


Here are the previous emails (in reverse cronological order) to make the scenario clear:

Hello Gasper,

Our publication is purely an educative one, meant for hobbyists and
enthusiasts. Our magazine is a well-read journal of 160 pages. We
print around 25,000 copies and every single copy is read by around 5-7
people, making our readership about 150,000. We get some advertising
in our magazine, which allows us to keep our cover price to INR 100.
And our aim is to showcase good photography. In light of this, we do
not offer a fee.

However, the prerogative to decline is entirely yours. But if you feel
you would be comfortable sharing the image with us please send us an
original high resolution file of the image.

Warm Regards
Neha
Email requesting terms and my normal publishing fee:
Hi Neha,

I can send you the high res images as required from my archives. Give me a couple of hours.

Meanwhile, since this is the first time, do let me know your terms of use etc. My normal magazine per image rate is .....

regards
#gasper

Response requesting high-res files of two photographs (no mention of terms).

Hello Gasper,

These are the images we would like to publish. I am attaching the image as well as the tag from the link you have sent.

The tag is : Other_Goa_12.jpg

The images should be 8x10-inches for Vertical images and 17x11.5-inches for Horizontal images at 300 dpi, so that if any image needs to be used a full-page bleed or as a double spread, we can.

Warm Regards
Neha


Initial email from me, following telephonic conversation, requesting images on Goa:

Hey Neha,

Sending you a few low-res pics that I dug out. Also check out the feature at: http://www.gasperdesouza.com/features/othergoa.htm

Let me know if any meet your requirements and terms of publishing. I can send you high-res file once finalised.

#gasper
I am all for helping causes and actively work in community media but I do not think a big media house is a "cause" that deserves free work - whether photography or other creative forms of expression.

I leave it to readers to judge.

NOTE: Better Photography is published by Infomedia 18 Ltd who also publish other big magazines like Chip (IT) and Overdrive (auto) with indirect control by TV 18 (CNBC TV 18 and CNBC Awaaz)

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Writing - key skill for digital-age journalists

Angela Grant has this interesting video interview with Micah Gelman, executive producer for domestic video, Associated Press. Gelman talks about how writing skills are the key in the new newsroom. All else can be learnt, he says.



His last sentence is most interesting: Who knows what the jobs are going to look like 5 years from now. But the basic skillset of being able to write will always get you somewhere.

Saturday, December 6, 2008

Using New Media - The Obama Way

Was helping out at a workshop on Online Advocacy today, facilitated by Freeman Murray.

Freeman used the Barrak Obama campaign as his case study to introduce participants to the New Media tools available to anyone willing to invest time, that's all.

Freeman began by telling the participants that this is not like any usual advertisement medium - it's not about buying space on television or in print and putting out your message. It's about building a community and that takes tons of time.

Corporates are keen to get their message across but activists often lag behind - they are too engrossed in fighting their battles in the real world to be bothered about the virtual world. McCain made that big mistake - his campaign overlooked the power of the internet for more traditional campaign strategies.

Obama, on the other hand, was willing to invest in building his community online. And he was able to win the hearts of millions. And he was prepared to listen to his community. And that is the crucial link that closes the chain - acknowledge the presence of your community and LISTEN.

So what were the tools of the campaign?

Well of course its good to start with a website to let the community know who you are and what you do. Obama used it to get people to fund his campaign and subscribe to his mailing list. He used this mailing list effectively to garner support at the drop of a hat. Then he made sure his supporters knew who he was and what he believed in. For this, he used his personal blog to get his views out there.

Don't have a website yet? You can start with the free Google Sites web page builder and Blogger for a free blog (like this one). Once you've got your feet wet you could go in for your own domain (like mine at gasperdesouza.com). It's cheap these days. But a website is just the beginning. How do you actually get people to come to your site?

Here's the Obama Way:

Facebook: 3,322,316 supporters, Youtube: 20,133,759 views, Flickr photos and Twitter: 143,496 followers.

By not getting online on the social networking sites, McCain lost the battle without a fight. When people went online to search for McCain, they were more likely to find material posted by Obama supporters than from the McCain camp. And therein lay the downfall.

There's loads of interesting stuff to read on New Media, on Freeman's blog, so I recommend you go check it out.

Building a community takes time. Spend it! Its a wise investment. Of course, before anything, make certain you have a message worth sharing!

Sunday, November 16, 2008

Learning from the great filmmakers

Just spent a full day watching films by the masters - Hitchcock (Rear Window), Godard (Breathless), Antonioni (Blowup!) - all part of a film appreciation workshop i am attending.

I generally watch films purely for the content, but for once I changed my perspective to look at them very technically.

An amazing lot to learn from the greats!

The use the power of suggestion through visuals alone - aka montages. It's quite revealing how, through simple placement of frames in set sequences, viewers can be led to make inferences. Quite similar in a photo essay - lay out the images in one sequence and you project one idea, change the sequence and it could result in a completely different inference. Rear Window, for instance, could easily have been a series of stills in a photo montage and, together with the excellent audio cues, would have made a great photo story.

Point of View also comes out strongly in rear window where, camera angles, what we see (and don't see) are all confined to the views of the wheelchair bound Jeff. Then there's Hitchcock's use of editing to compress / elongate time - even with simple fades. This is a key in editing video sequences - keep the key components in the activity and imply the rest. Also, his use of the panning camera at the start of Rear Window to set the scene in space. This is an excellent example of when a pan is called for.

Of course, this idea of panning is turned on its head by Godard in Breathless. He uses some very long sequences without any cuts - the camera follows the actors around in the figure 8 movement. Then there are the many instances where he breaks the fundamental rule of 180 degree axis of viewing, taking the camera from one side of the axis to the opposite. How many video shooting manuals will tell us never cross the axis - it disorients the viewer. But Godard seeks to do just that - disorient us.

And the most fundamental way the does this is with hundreds of "jump cuts". He literally stitches together scenes (using anti-aesthetic cut points), creating "jumps". For instance: Jean-Paul Belmondo and Jean Seberg are engaged in a discussion in a bedroom, Belmondo seated on the bed, in one frame and in the very next Belmondo is standing by Seberg by the cupboard. It is quite disconcerting, when did he get off the bed? These jumps happen repeatedly through the film.


By breaking the rules, Godard gives us a better understanding of the smooth cuts in editing - let the action leave the frame before the cut etc. Generally we would be told let Belmondo begin to get off the bed, then show him in the next scene standing by the cupboard - continuity.

First do the right thing and then break the rules - knowing you are doing so.

David Dunkley Gyimah of viewmagazine.tv executes this technique in video journalism, calling it anti-aesthetic edits using jerky camera movements, disconcertingly jerky/jump cuts, grain. But again, this technique can be appreciated and executed only once the rules are known. He is today's Godard in video journalism.

Break the rules once you know what you are breaking.

Of course, by simply watching Godard's cuts in Breathless, it could easily be construed as being "badly edited".
Isn't that what a lot of art provokes us to say!

The workshop, held at the newly opened center for the arts - Sunapranta, is being facilitated by Anuja Ghosalkar, Programme Executive for Arts Research and Documentation at the India Foundation for the Arts. She curated the Tri-Continental Human Rights Film Festival 2007 and is a trained lecturer in literature and mass media. She has worked with a number of film projects including Channel 4.

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Seismic changes in photojournalism

The road ahead | S Gasper D'Souza

The seismic changes in photojournalism that have been expected for some time now, seem to be upon us in a big way. After Nikon announced its D90, capable of shooting HD video, Canon today announced the EOS 5D Mark II capable of shooting HD and SD video and, what's more, it take stereo audio inputs (Nikon failed on the audio front).

According to the Canon USA press note (http://www.usa.canon.com/templatedata/pressrelease/20080917_5dmkii.html)

Answering the question of where SLR technology is going next, the EOS 5D Mark II features 16:9 Full HD video capture at 1920 x 1080 pixels and 30 fps as well as 4:3 standard TV quality (SD) video capture at 640 x 480 pixels and 30 fps, both capabilities appearing for the first time in a Canon SLR camera.

The new camera features an input terminal for external stereo microphones as well as a built-in monaural microphone for convenience.

This proves that integrated visual solutions are here to stay. Photojournalists can now look to shooting stills and video with the same camera and more importantly, use the same SLR lenses for creative control - wide, tele, shallow depth of field...the works.

...including everything from ultra-wide-angle and fish-eye to macro and super-telephoto, including many large-aperture L-series professional lenses that can keep the main subject in razor-sharp focus while blurring the background beyond recognition.

With both the majors having seen the need to merge stills with video, there's no excuse for stalling any more.

The revolution is on!

Sunday, August 17, 2008

The smart PJ follows his Cheese



The winds of change are sweeping across the photojournalism world and the concept of a photojournalist is re-shaping, even as I write this. Experiments are already well under way in press rooms of far-thinking newspapers, headed by the visions of hardcore photojournalists.

Some call it blasphemous. The death of photojournalism. At 30fps, does it all amount to having the fastest motordrive? Is video the future for photojournalists? There is no proof yet, but the indications are very much evident.

Fact. Print media offers limited scope for good photojournalism. As news holes reduce, space for images is limited to the single (or, at best two) large “candyfloss” photos catering to page design more than PJ content. In such a scenario, the PJ has been sidelined to the point of becoming secondary, dancing to the whims of everyone else in the newsroom. He was a dying breed.

Then came the re-awakening. The Internet boom brought in new and exciting opportunities for all. To the visionary PJ, it provided a space to showcase him true capabilities. It offered him a chance to carry out indepth work and let the world see the outcome.

A number of PJs at newspapers, especially in the US (Washington Post being a pionier among these), realised the potential and began putting up simple slide shows - collections of images brought into the newsroom that could not make it to print. Soon, the smart PJs started capturing sounds – field interviews and ambient sounds, setting these to the images in slideshows. Audio slideshows became a hit online. Today, the venerable Magnum has its own multimedia version in the Magnum InMotion project where audio is infused into images to create spellbinding audio slideshows.

From these beginings, it was just a matter of time before the idea of capturing video was thrown into the ring. Today a number of newspapers, notably the Dallas Morning News under the guidance of David Leelson (a strong advocate of video for PJs), routinely use video exclusively in the field. Single frames are “grabbed” and used in print while video presentations go online. Talk about getting the best of both worlds with little fuss!

High Definition video (HDV) is the technology that makes this possible. The use of HDV in pressrooms can only increase as the tech improves. The concept of a PJ as someone capturing “photos” will change. What we will have are hybrid entities capable of capturing photos, video and sound from the field and amalgamating that into slick Flash presentations online with the print editions using a few frames as secondary outlets.

It is really a matter of when, not whether. The smart PJs are already at work, experimenting with this new medium of expression. The tools may change. But this is one way we have found to survive and continue with our passion – which is making good images.

The cheese has moved, it's time to move to new cheese.

Sunday, August 10, 2008

Why Multimedia Journalism?

I am a photojournalist and love working on longer projects. But the more I think of it, the more I am convinced, the print news industry is simply not the equipped for good visual work. Now don't get me wrong. It's amazing to see your work printed in 5-6 columns in the print edition. But, how often do you see that in newspapers? More often that not, all a pj can expect is a small 2-3 column space squeezed in between ads and text. The news space (or news hole) is constantly decreasing.

Unfortunately for pjs in India, newspapers are making good money and are content to let things be. Unlike their counterparts in the US and UK (who are struggling with falling readership and revenues), publishers in India see no real purpose of an online edition other than “Yea, its good to be there”.

But to me the most exciting aspect of the internet is the freedom to choose the medium to best convey the story. Add to that, the absence of the usual print constraint of “lack of space” and we have a killer combination. On the internet, a story could be told using any or all media based on the requirement – audio for the cracking voice of the ageing mother, video for a tour of the hell in which she works, still images of the emotions as her tired face lights up on sight of her newborn grandson and text for the background issues involving people living on the street. Now you get the idea.